David Enoch
Hebrew University of Jerusalem

Associate Professor of Philosophy and Jacob I. Berman Associate Professor of Law, the Hebrew University of Jerusalem. I thank Alon Harel, Andrei Marmor, Ori Simchen, Saul Smilansky and Ben Zipurski for detailed and helpful comments on an earlier draft. I am also grateful to the participants in the conference on Moral and Legal Luck at the Hebrew University and Tel Aviv University, in January 2007, and the Analytic Legal Philosophy Conference in April 2007 for helpful discussions. For supporting the research for this paper, I am grateful to the Israel Science Foundation.